There's just one little problem with the planned purchases of EMI: they might not happen! According to a stern email just sent to Digital Music News by indie consortium Impala, a combination of Universal Music Group and EMI is highly likely to catch the ire of European regulators. "Given that Brussels has taken a previous decision that Universal should not be any bigger, we would
expect the sale to Universal to be blocked outright, even if it offers to increase the divestments it is prepared to make," said Helen Smith, Executive Chair of IMPALA. "The same would apply to Sony if it buys EMI publishing."
This is Impala's moment to stir a tsunami, and Smith pointed to a board meeting in less than 10 days. "Impala takes the view that even if Universal proposes to increase the £500 million divestments it is prepared to make, the deal will not be accepted," Smith continued.
But wait: who cares about Impala, anyway? Universal Music Group, Citigroup, Sony, and a bunch of investors that include David Geffen, that's who. Impala is the group that successfully forced a second review of the Sony BMG joint venture in 2007, a massive distraction of paperwork, formalities, and government meetings. The Sony BMG carriage pushed through those muddied tracks, though ultimately, the ill-fated handshake was canceled for broader reasons.
Now, Impala is threatening a similar muscle-flex. And before the ink was dry on the EMI negotiation, Impala promised to issue a strong challenge. "The last time the European Commission looked at Universal, it ordered the company to sell off assets to cut it down to an acceptable size," the group continued. "Since that decision, Universal has grown, which makes it even less likely that the regulators would accept any new acquisitions.
There's another piece of luggage in the baggage set: Live Nation. After Universal Music announced a fairly substantial tie-up with the concert giant, Impala issued formal complaints with the European Commission. So we'll just add this to the pile.

Comments Closed
@angeliquemiles Friday, November 11, 2011
Angelique Miles
Not so fast...

great news Friday, November 11, 2011
Good to see that the bankers are facing opposition.

aa Friday, November 11, 2011
Best title picture ever!

@thomaslindqvist Friday, November 11, 2011
Thomas
yeah, UMG + EMI sounds like trouble to me.

Food For Thought Friday, November 11, 2011
Lightly dismiss Helen Smith at your own peril. She's one of the brightest minds and most determined advocates in the global music industry.
Impala, Merlin, SoundExchange, A2IM, AIM...for the 1st time ever indie labels have real representation and muscle. If you run an indie label and don't know how these organizations are helping your business you should find out and get involved.

A. Nonymous Saturday, November 12, 2011
If you think SoundExchange is representing the interests of Indy labels (other than accidentally when those interests perfectly allign with those of the majors), you are delusional.

@Charlottevkotze Monday, November 14, 2011
EMI's acquisition by Universal was an illusion. Now, reality is coming back & it's relieving for independent labels

MalcolmG Monday, November 14, 2011
The placating starting block would be folding Fontana and ELS and getting out of indie distribution. Now that this isn't counted as part of their marketshare, what's the point? It's a small margin business, 18% vs more than 100% in a 360 deal, catalog sales are a dead issue, and their only enabling the competition in a narrowing field.
ADA and RED can have this distraction, and probably Impala's approval as well.

London Music Mapp Monday, November 14, 2011
Both companies seem to have money to burn on lawyers fees but in the end Universal and EMI will merge in some form or other and then bought by Google or Apple.
Meanwhile staff both at Universal and EMI will have months of uncertainty, neither company will be hiring much needed staff, productivity falls and bands get dropped or worse still their albums are allowed to escape rather than be released over the next year.
We have all been here before, many times. The recorded music market is shrinking and sales are falling at a time of unprecedented global economic crisis.
Still at least the lawyers, accountants and bankers will be earning money, which is of great solace to the rest of us.
Anyone got any good lawyer/accountant/banker jokes?
www.londonmusicmapp.com

@InkRecords Monday, November 14, 2011
Ink Records
Interested to see how this pans out...makes sense
OUR SPONSORS
Follow Us